Home arrow BrainDump arrow Page 4 - Tomcat Benchmark Procedure

What else we could have benchmarked - BrainDump

In this third part of a five-part series focusing on Tomcat performance tuning, you will learn benchmarking procedures and some of the qualities of the application that you can benchmark. This article is excerpted from chapter four of Tomcat: The Definitive Guide, Second Edition, written by Jason Brittain and Ian F. Darwin (O'Reilly; ISBN: 0596101066). Copyright © 2008 O'Reilly Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Used with permission from the publisher. Available from booksellers or direct from O'Reilly Media.

  1. Tomcat Benchmark Procedure
  2. Benchmark results and summary
  3. Benchmark results and summary continued
  4. What else we could have benchmarked
By: O'Reilly Media
Rating: starstarstarstarstar / 2
February 26, 2009

print this article



In this benchmark, we tested the web server’s performance when serving HTTP. We did not benchmark HTTPS (encrypted HTTP). The performance characteristics are probably significantly different between HTTP and HTTPS because with HTTPS, both the server and the client must encrypt and decrypt the data in both directions over the network. The overhead caused by the encryption slows down the requests and responses to varying degrees on different implementations of the crypto code. We have not benchmarked the HTTPS performance of the above web server configurations. Without benchmarking it, many believe that Apache httpd’s HTTPS performance is higher than that of Tomcat, and usually people base that belief on the idea that C code is faster than Java code. Our HTTP benchmark disproves that in three out of our four benchmark scenarios, and the fourth one is not significantly better on the C side. We do not know which web server configuration would be fastest serving HTTPS without benchmarking them. But, if either the C encryption code or the Java encryption code is the fastest—by a significant margin—Tomcat implements both because you can configure the APR connector to use OpenSSL for HTTPS encryption, which is the same C library that Apache httpd uses. 

We could have benchmarked other metrics such as throughput; there are many more interesting things to learn by watching any particular metric that ab reports. For this benchmark, we define greater performance to mean a higher number of requests per second being handled successfully (a 2xx response code).

We could have benchmarked other static file sizes, including files larger than 9k in size, but with files as large as 100k, all of the involved server configurations saturate the bandwidth of a megabit Ethernet network. This makes it impossible to measure how fast the server software itself could serve the files because the network was not fast enough. For our test, we did not have network bandwidth greater than 1 Mb Ethernet.

We could have tested with mixed file sizes per HTTP request, but what mixture would we choose, and what use case would that particular mixture represent? The results of benchmarks such as these would only be interesting if your own web traffic had a similar enough mixture, which is unlikely. Instead, we focused on benchmarking two file sizes, one file size per benchmark test.

We could have tested with a different number of client threads, but 150 threads is the default (as of this writing) on both Tomcat and Apache httpd, which means many administrators will use these settings—mainly due to lack of time to learn what the settings do and how to change them in a useful way. We ended up raising some of the limits on the Apache httpd side to try to find a way to make httpd perform better when the benchmark client sends a maximum of 149 concurrent requests; it worked.

There are many other things we could have benchmarked and many other ways we could have benchmarked. Even covering other common use cases is beyond the scope of this book. We’re trying to show only one example of a benchmark that yields some useful information about how the performance of Tomcat’s web server implementations compares with that of Apache httpd in a specific limited environment and for specific tests.

Please check back next week for the continuation of this article.

>>> More BrainDump Articles          >>> More By O'Reilly Media

blog comments powered by Disqus
escort Bursa Bursa escort Antalya eskort


- Apple Founder Steve Jobs Dies
- Steve Jobs` Era at Apple Ends
- Google's Chrome Developer Tool Updated
- Google's Chrome 6 Browser Brings Speed to th...
- New Open Source Update Fedora 13 is Released...
- Install Linux with Knoppix
- iPad Developers Flock To SDK 3.2
- Managing a Linux Wireless Access Point
- Maintaining a Linux Wireless Access Point
- Securing a Linux Wireless Access Point
- Configuring a Linux Wireless Access Point
- Building a Linux Wireless Access Point
- Migrating Oracle to PostgreSQL with Enterpri...
- Demystifying SELinux on Kernel 2.6
- Yahoo and Microsoft Create Ad Partnership

Developer Shed Affiliates


Dev Shed Tutorial Topics: